Beyond the Tick Box: Why Generic Safety Systems Put Your Business at Risk

Across New Zealand, and increasingly here in Taupo, we are seeing the negative effects of “cookie cutter” or “tick and flick” health and safety systems. These are generic, one-size-fits-all packages that claim to offer compliance, but in reality do little to improve safety or meet the intent of the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015.

The problem with these systems is simple: they’re not made for your business. They often come as off-the-shelf folders or templated online portals, loaded with irrelevant documents that are never read, never understood, and certainly never used. Workers are left disengaged. Managers tick boxes to show something exists. But when something goes wrong, these systems fall apart — because they were never designed for the real risks of the actual work being done.

A simple way to test whether your health and safety system is genuinely fit-for-purpose is the “Coca-Cola test”. If you can take your policy, procedure, or safety plan and change the company name to Coca-Cola — and everything still makes sense — you could be in trouble. That’s a clear sign your system is too generic to reflect your risks, your people, or your operations.

In Taupo, we’ve reviewed systems that include emergency plans for chemicals the company doesn’t use, training records signed off with no evidence of delivery, safety manuals referencing the Department of Labour (became Worksafe in 2013) and the old Health and Safety in Employment Act 1992 (repealed, April 2016). It’s not just poor practice — it undermines the credibility of health and safety and could expose business owners to real legal and financial risk.

These generic systems don’t just fail operationally — they’re also easy to spot by those who know what to look for. Whether it’s experienced health and safety professionals, external auditors, or pre-qualification assessors for tenders, a cookie cutter approach stands out for all the wrong reasons. It weakens your business brand and can limit your ability to win contracts where quality systems are expected.

Even for businesses that aren’t applying for tenders or formal audits, these systems are a poor investment. If your goal is to genuinely keep people safe and engaged, your team needs simple, relevant, and practical systems they can trust and actually use. A generic policy no one reads won’t change behaviour or reduce risk. But a tailored, well-communicated approach will — and it builds a stronger, more connected team culture in the process.

There’s also a serious governance risk. Directors and business owners who rely on dashboards or reports generated from these tick-box systems can be lulled into a false sense of security. If something goes wrong, claiming ignorance won’t protect you — especially if the systems in place were clearly not fit for purpose. Under the Health and Safety at Work Act, officers have a duty to exercise due diligence. That includes actively verifying that the systems in use are effective, and that the information they’re receiving reflects what’s really happening on the ground.

At Lakes Safety Services, we take a different approach. We work alongside your team, understand your work, and build systems that are practical, understandable, and specific to your risks. If it’s not relevant, we leave it out. If it matters, we make sure it’s done well.

Good health and safety is not about having the thickest folder — it’s about having the right tools, in the right places, used by people who know why it matters. If you’re ready to move beyond the cookie cutter, get in touch. We’ll help you build something that works.

A Practical Health Monitoring Guide for Employers

A worker develops a persistent cough after months of cutting fibre-cement sheet, or a painter starts experiencing skin irritation that does not settle between shifts. By the time the symptoms are obvious, the opportunity to prevent harm may have passed. A practical health monitoring guide for employers helps identify health changes early, while there is […]

Read More

eLearning Software for Bay of Plenty Businesses — Take Control of Your Training

Businesses across the Bay of Plenty are increasingly looking for better ways to train their people, manage competency and keep reliable training records. Spreadsheets, PowerPoint presentations and paper sign-offs can work when a business is small. But as teams grow, sites become more complex or training requirements increase, those systems become harder to manage. Bracken […]

Read More

Safe Working at Heights

At Lakes Safety Services, we specialise in high-risk work safety, with a particular focus on working at heights. Our expert health and safety consultancy strictly adheres to the Health and Safety at Work Act 2015, WorkSafe NZ guidelines, AS/NZS standards, and NZQA unit standards. By integrating these requirements into our practices, we ensure robust safety […]

Read More

Hear It from Our Clients

See the impact we've had on businesses and how we could do the same for you.

We can’t speak highly enough of Lake Safety Services and Derek in particular. Rather than applying a cookie-cutter template, Derek took the time to genuinely understand our business and our processes before putting anything together. The result was a health and safety solution that fits like a glove – tailored, practical, and clearly built around how we actually operate, not just a generic checklist. If you’re after a consultancy that treats your business as unique rather than “one of many,” Derek and the team at Lake Safety Services are the ones to call!

Jacques Schoeman
Director

MAD Media Ltd – New Plymouth

Highly recommend this health and safety company! They provided top-notch service for our roofing business, ensuring everything was up to standard. Their team was professional, thorough, and easy to work with. We feel confident knowing our safety measures are in excellent hands. Great job.

Laurence
Director

 

Storm Tech Roofing – Hawkes Bay

We are a small yet complex organisation and have been working with Derek for the past year with the goal of creating a robust health and safety system that is maintained through internal ownership and embedded into business as usual. While Derek is knowledgeable, professional, and enthusiastic, his real superpower is working alongside the team to create a system which is tailored and practical, all while growing internal capacity. We would absolutely recommend Derek.

Lake Taupo Hospice

Through Derek, Lakes Safety Services provided an extremely thorough and personalised service to Broadlands School. Derek’s scope was the review the school’s EOTC practices and to make recommednations in changes to policy and day to day management practices including practical EOTC staff documentation. This brief was very well achieved! Derek has also provided great follow up service and a willingness to assist with any future EOTC draft policies before being adopted by the Board.

Graeme Taylor
Principal

Broadlands School

Derek was approachable, experienced, and readily available (at very short notice) for what was required for our H&S work site induction. Highly recommend should your company be in need of a person to tackle H&S matters.

Grace Solomon
Resident Manager

Two Trees Ngā Rākau e Rua – Taupō

We had a great experience with Lakes Safety. Derek provided practical, on-site support for our small business, taking the time to look at what we already had in place and offering straightforward guidance on how we could improve our systems.

He was very easy to chat with and came up with practical, workable solutions that actually fit our business. He really does make health and safety much easier and more manageable for a small business.

Carolyn Inglis
Director

Taupo Employment Services

As a business, we’ve had a fantastic experience working with Lakes Safety Services: professional, reliable, and highly knowledgeable, making every interaction seamless from start to finish.

The commitment to people, safety, clear communication, and attention to detail gives us complete confidence in the services provided.

We highly recommend Lakes Safety Services to any business or individual. They’ve shown us that health and safety doesn’t have to be complicated. Practical approach and expert guidance have made a real difference to our business and our staff.

Mirela Petrar
Operations Manager

Taupo DeBretts

Derek provided excellent health & safety consultancy. His advice was practical, thorough, well-delivered, and easy to implement. He helped us identify risks we’d overlooked and suggested cost-effective solutions. Recommend for any business needing H&S guidance.

Murray Beadle
General Manager

BFA Business Advisors and Accountants – Taupo

Working with Derek is a pleasant change from the usual tick box H & S consultant. He is very practical and gets the job done with results that we could all work with.

Alan Bullick
President

Taupo Deerstalkers (NZDA)

I got Derek in to update our H&S management system. He was honest and did a great job. Highly recommend.

Mark Bowsher
Station Manager

Whareroa Station – Waikato

Thank you, Derek, for your professional and objective advice. Your insights were incredibly helpful. We also really appreciated your enthusiasm in sharing your social networks and experiences, it was truly inspiring!

Eve Liu
Office Manager

Hauraki Civil Engineering – Rotorua

Very knowledgeable and willing to put the effort in upfront to understand our situation. Tailored things to fit our business requirements without creating a pile of confusing admin for us.

Spenser Christiansen
Director

That Dingo Guy – Manawatu

Practical Health and Safety Support That Works

Experience You Can Rely On

With over 30 years of real-world experience, Lakes Safety Services helps businesses manage risk, build practical safety systems, manage contractors, complete SafePlus assessments and improve health and safety governance — without unnecessary paperwork or complexity.